Can You Defer Prosecution for a DUI in Washington State?

Can You Defer Prosecution for a DUI in Tacoma, WA?

If you’ve been arrested for driving under the influence in Tacoma or elsewhere in Pierce County, it can feel like your life is suddenly on hold. A DUI charge in Washington carries serious consequences, including jail exposure, heavy fines, mandatory treatment, license suspension, and long-term damage to your record. Many people immediately ask a very practical question: Is there a way to avoid a DUI conviction altogether?

One option that sometimes comes up is deferred prosecution. Deferred prosecution is a real legal mechanism in Washington, but it is often misunderstood. It is not a shortcut, and it is not available to everyone. In many cases, it can be more demanding than a standard DUI sentence.

At Smith & White, we regularly help Tacoma DUI clients evaluate whether deferred prosecution makes sense—or whether a traditional defense strategy offers a better long-term outcome.

What Is Deferred Prosecution in a Washington DUI Case?

Deferred prosecution is a statutory option under Washington law that allows certain defendants to avoid a conviction only if they complete an extensive treatment-based program. Instead of entering a guilty finding, the court pauses the case while the defendant undergoes treatment for an underlying condition that allegedly caused the DUI.

If you successfully complete the program and comply with all court conditions, the DUI charge is dismissed. If you fail at any point, the case comes back to court and the judge can impose a DUI conviction and sentence.

Deferred prosecution is not a dismissal, and it is not the same as getting charges dropped. It is a long-term legal commitment that places strict requirements on your life for several years.

Deferred Prosecution Is About Treatment, Not Innocence

One of the most important things to understand is that deferred prosecution requires you to formally acknowledge that:

• Your DUI resulted from alcoholism, drug addiction, or a qualifying mental health condition
• You need treatment for that condition

This matters. Deferred prosecution is not available if you are maintaining that you were not impaired, that the stop was unlawful, or that the evidence is flawed. In contrast, a traditional DUI defense allows your attorney to challenge the stop, the arrest, the breath or blood test, and the prosecution’s evidence.

Deferred prosecution shifts the focus away from guilt or innocence and toward rehabilitation.

Who Is Eligible for DUI Deferred Prosecution in Washington?

Deferred prosecution is not automatic and requires court approval. Eligibility depends on several factors, including your criminal history and the facts of your case.

In general, you must be able to show that your DUI was caused by one of the following:

• Alcohol use disorder
• Drug addiction
• A qualifying mental health condition

You must also be willing to commit to long-term treatment and monitoring.

While first-time DUI defendants are more commonly approved, prior DUI history does not automatically disqualify someone. However, courts scrutinize repeat offenders much more closely.

What Does the Deferred Prosecution Program Require?

Deferred prosecution is often described as one of the most demanding outcomes available in a DUI case. Typical requirements include:

• A professional chemical dependency or mental health evaluation
• Enrollment in a state-approved treatment program
• Intensive outpatient treatment, often lasting two years
• Ongoing aftercare and monitoring
• Abstinence from alcohol and non-prescribed drugs
• Regular court reviews and compliance hearings
• Ignition interlock requirements
• Payment of treatment costs, court fees, and monitoring expenses

The court maintains jurisdiction over your case for up to five years. Any violation—missed appointments, positive tests, or new legal trouble—can result in termination from the program.

How Deferred Prosecution Affects Your Driver’s License

Deferred prosecution does not automatically protect your driving privileges. The Washington Department of Licensing operates independently from the criminal court.

In most DUI cases, you still face:

• Administrative license suspension
• Ignition interlock requirements
• SR-22 insurance

Many Tacoma DUI clients are surprised to learn that even if they enter deferred prosecution, they must still address DOL consequences separately.

Deferred Prosecution vs. Fighting the DUI Charge

Deferred prosecution is only one possible outcome. It is not always the best option.

In some cases, a strong DUI defense may lead to:

• Suppression of key evidence
• Reduction to a lesser charge such as reckless driving or negligent driving
• Dismissal due to legal or procedural errors

Unlike deferred prosecution, these outcomes do not require years of treatment or an admission of an underlying condition.

This is why consulting with an experienced Tacoma DUI defense attorney before requesting deferred prosecution is critical. Once requested, it can be difficult to undo.

A Realistic Tacoma DUI Scenario (Hypothetical)

Imagine a Tacoma resident arrested for a first-time DUI after a traffic stop late at night. The driver has no criminal history and cooperates with police. Breath test results are close to the legal limit.

One option is deferred prosecution, which would require at least two years of treatment, five years of court supervision, and strict abstinence.

Another option is a traditional defense strategy, where the attorney challenges the legality of the stop and the breath test procedure. If successful, the case could be reduced or dismissed without long-term supervision.

The right choice depends on the evidence, the client’s goals, and their personal circumstances.

Is Deferred Prosecution a “Free Pass” for DUI?

No. Deferred prosecution is often more demanding than a standard DUI sentence. It requires time, money, emotional commitment, and complete lifestyle changes. For some people, it is the right choice. For others, it creates unnecessary risk.

Deferred prosecution should be viewed as a treatment-focused alternative, not an easy way out.

Is Deferred Prosecution Limited to One Time?

For many years, Washington law treated deferred prosecution for DUI as a one-time option. If you used deferred prosecution once, it was generally unavailable again for any future DUI or physical control charge. That long-standing rule made the decision to pursue deferred prosecution especially serious.

Recent changes to Washington law have softened that absolute lifetime bar, but only in very limited circumstances. Under current statutes, a person who previously completed a deferred prosecution may, in rare cases, be eligible to request another deferred prosecution later. This is not automatic and requires strict compliance with statutory criteria and court approval.

In practical terms, courts still treat deferred prosecution as an extraordinary remedy, not a routine outcome. Courts continue to scrutinize requests closely, and most people should assume they may only have one meaningful opportunity to use deferred prosecution in their lifetime.

Because the law in this area has evolved, it is critical to speak with an experienced Tacoma DUI attorney before requesting deferred prosecution. Using it prematurely—or unnecessarily—can eliminate future options that may be more appropriate down the road.

Deferred Prosecution and Immigration Consequences

If you are not a United States citizen, deferred prosecution can carry serious immigration risks that are often overlooked.

To qualify for deferred prosecution in a Washington DUI case, you must formally swear—under oath—that your offense was caused by alcoholism, drug addiction, or a qualifying mental health condition. That sworn admission becomes part of the court record. While it may help resolve a criminal case, it can create problems in immigration proceedings later.

• Federal immigration authorities may treat these admissions as evidence of:

• A substance abuse disorder

• Drug dependency

• Mental health conditions relevant to admissibility or removability

• In some situations, these sworn statements can be used against a person applying for all very many forms of immigration relieft.

Importantly, immigration law operates independently of Washington criminal courts. Even if a DUI charge is dismissed after deferred prosecution, the underlying admissions may still be reviewed by immigration officials.

For non-citizens—including lawful permanent residents—this means deferred prosecution may resolve the criminal case but complicate or foreclose immigration relief later. Because these consequences are highly fact-specific, anyone with immigration concerns should consult with both a Tacoma DUI defense attorney and an immigration attorney before requesting deferred prosecution.

Once those admissions are made, they generally cannot be undone.

How a Tacoma DUI Attorney Helps You Decide

At Smith & White, we do not push clients into deferred prosecution. We evaluate:

The strength of the State’s evidence

Prior criminal and DUI history

DOL consequences

Long-term employment and licensing concerns

Treatment readiness and personal goals

Only after reviewing the full picture do we advise whether deferred prosecution is worth pursuing.

Talk to a Tacoma DUI Defense Lawyer Before Making This Decision

In our experience, many people underestimate how permanently this decision can shape future DUI exposure.   Making the wrong choice can cost you years of supervision and thousands of dollars.

If you are facing a DUI charge in Tacoma or Pierce County, get legal advice early. Understanding your options now can protect your future.

Facing DUI charges? Don’t navigate the system alone—reach out to our Tacoma office today for a free consultation.