Hire us to reduce time and stress. Sign up by email. Appear through counsel under new rule CrR 3.4.
Get updates through our encrypted client portal.

Justia Lawyer Rating
AV Preeminent
Avvo Client's Choice Award 2018
Avvo Rating 10 - Top Attorney
BBB Business Accredited
2019 Champion of Justice
Expertise Best Criminal Defense Attorneys in Kent 2022

Right to Confront Expert Witness (Toxicologist) That Performed the Test in Tacoma DUI Cases

Right to Confront Expert Witness (Toxicologist) That Performed the Test in Tacoma DUI Cases Under the United States Constitution and Washington law, both of which apply to your Tacoma criminal case, DUI, assault domestic violence or otherwise, people accused of crimes have the right to confront the prosecution’s witnesses against them. If they are denied that right or the prosecution’s witness is unavailable, it may constitute grounds for dismissing the charges against them. Recently, a Washington court discussed the right to confront witnesses in a case in which it dismissed DUI charges against a defendant because the prosecution’s key witness was unavailable. If you are charged with a DUI offense, it is wise to confer with a Tacoma DUI defense lawyer regarding what measures you may be able to take to seek a favorable outcome.

The Factual and Procedural History of the Case

It is alleged that a police officer stopped the defendant’s car due to a headlight violation. After the officer talked to the defendant, he suspected he was intoxicated and asked him to submit to a breath test. The defendant refused, and the officer obtained a warrant for a blood draw. Two vials of the defendant’s blood were collected and sent to a crime lab, where a toxicologist performed an analysis and issued a report setting forth her findings.

Reportedly, the defendant’s blood alcohol level was over the legal limit, and he was charged with DUI. The case proceeded to trial, but the prosecution declined to call the toxicologist on the grounds that she no longer worked for the city. Instead, it moved to admit her report through another party that signed it as a reviewer. The defendant objected to the motion on the grounds that it violated his right to confront the witnesses against him. The court denied the motion but the city appealed, and the appellate court reversed the trial court ruling. The defendant then appealed.

The Right to Confront Witnesses

On appeal, the court addressed the issue of whether the admission of the toxicology report via the reviewer would violate the defendant’s right to confrontation. The court noted that the reviewer did not modify the toxicology report in any way so as to demonstrate the defendant’s guilt.  Accordingly, the court found that the trial court’s determination that allowing the introduction of the toxicology report via the reviewer’s testimony instead of through the testimony of the toxicologist would violate the defendant’s right to confrontation. As such, the court dismissed the charges against the defendant.

Talk to a Trusted Tacoma Criminal Defense Lawyer

The prosecution will often rely on testimony from toxicologists to establish a defendant's guilt in DUI cases, and if such witnesses are unavailable, the defendant may be able to argue that the charges against them should be dismissed. If you are accused of a DUI crime, it is prudent to talk to an attorney about your options for seeking a ruling in your favor. The trusted Tacoma criminal defense lawyers of The Law Offices of Smith & White can inform you of your rights and aid you in seeking the best legal result possible under the facts of your case. You can reach us through our online form or by calling us at 253-203-1645 to set up a conference.

Client Reviews
I was represented by James White and have been nothing but satisfied with the outcome. Jame is very efficient and eliminates much of the stress that the judicial system can place on an offender. I am very grateful to have such a great attorney and owe him my gratitude for helping me when times were rough. Not only is he professional, but he is also someone you can talk to on a personal level. I highly recommend James White and would undoubtedly use him again in the future. If you are in search of an attorney, do yourself a favor and have the law offices of Smith & White represent you. Mike D.
I contacted James after my charge for reckless endangerment, and right from the start he was informative and reassuring. James worked hard to get me the best possible outcome, and was always very quick to return a call or text. He was straightforward and honest with me about my case, explaining both the good and the bad in a way that was reassuring without being misleading. Overall, I highly recommend Smith and White to anyone who is looking for the most professional representation in their legal matters. Matthew B.
Attorney James White was a beacon of hope for me at a time when my options appeared limited and the likeness of a satisfactory resolution seemed close to nothing. Not only was he able to defend me in a specific sticky situation in which I hired him for, I felt as though he also went above and beyond in efforts to provide me with the best outcome possible. His calm and professional demeanor offered such a great assurance to myself and those I care about around me. I am completely grateful for his service and I most definitely recommend Mr. White. Leyasha J.
Derek Smith guided us through a troubling legal situation with absolute professionalism. This was my first experience with a trial situation and Mr. Smith was able to address all of my questions and concerns in a way that helped address some of the fear I had regarding the legal system. Mr. Smith was highly effective during the trial and the result ended up in our favor. Legal troubles are scary and it was great knowing we had a fantastic legal team on our side to help navigate the somewhat confusing situation. My wife and I emphatically recommend this law firm. Steve B.
Mr. Smith was wonderful to work with. He was professional, knowledgeable and effective!! He takes the time to listen, which is amazing and can be a hard quality to find! He is informative and straight forward, which I truly appreciate! He was quite helpful on another matter that I asked his advise on. Thank you!!! Melika